Compare products

Cons [188] of Lash Sensational Volumizing and Thicke..	Strength
complete waste in both products "however was a complete waste of money"	99.9%
total waste in both products "how unhygienic and a total waste of money as i don’t trust to you use it so it’s been binned"	99.8%
very disappointed in both products "will not buy this brand again very disappointed"	99.0%
only problem in both products "the only problem about this is it can make a mess because it’s too much on the brush"	74.5%
black smudges in both products "there’s no clumping and doesn’t leave black smudges when wearing throughout the day"	74.3%
waste of money in both products "waste of money"	66.7%
much product in both products "the wand gathers too much product and no matter how much i try to clear the brush it always ends up being too much leaving me with clumpy eyelashes and a lot of smudges"	65.7%
hair & fine "this i'll stick with my usual benefit tho i have fine hair & fine lashes not enough oomph for me"	98.4%
awful clumpy "its awful clumpy and makes my lashes look nasty !"	97.6%
really swollen "i like the bold and thick effect however my eyes got really swollen after only 2 days of usage"	97.6%
horrible mascara "horrible mascara the worst i've ever had!"	91.9%
sucked into "i don't usually get sucked into ads but i'm always looking for the best mascara"	88.5%
worst mascara "it's by far the worst mascara i have ever used!"	88.0%
avoided clumping "this mascara is definitely one of the best mascaras i've used i really liked the shape of the brush which fit my eye shape and avoided clumping"	87.7%
worst energy "i would not recommend this mascara to my worst energy"	85.8%
smudge alittle "waterproof side of it when they get wet they don't run but if you touch them whilst wet with water and the dried top layer comes off it does tend to smudge alittle but i find this with most waterproof mascaras"	74.9%
doesnt even "and it doesnt make my eyes water like alot of other mascaras it doesnt even feel like i'm wearing mascara"	74.9%
fake lashes "fab product only way to get more volume than this is fake lashes!"	74.9%
black circles "i’ve been using it for a few years and find it’s the only mascara that doesn’t leave black circles round my eyes at the end of the night and it doesn’t irritate my eyes"	74.9%
sweaty mess "wear it when i go running and even when i’m a sweaty mess it stays put!"	74.9%
remove only "easy to remove only if you use nivea gentle wipe"	74.9%
creating lumps "it seems to have clearly been used as when trying to apply it there isn’t much inside of the bottle for application in which i need to dip it quite a few times to get enough to apply but creating lumps"	74.9%
seems unsanitary "unfortunately i just bought another one from the same listing and it arrived without a hygiene seal with the barcode sticker haphazardly stuck on the top of the component kinda gross and i ended up binning it because that seems unsanitary and i don’t want to risk putting something possibly used near my eyes"	74.8%
expiration date "in my view products with an expiration date should always be sealed"	74.8%
maybelline cheap "i have always stuck with maybelline cheap and cheerful but still good!"	74.8%
more expensive "i only wish i never wasted my money on the more expensive brands"	74.8%
wearing fake "this stuff lengthens and thickens to make it look like you are wearing fake lashes it gives me the same effect as much higher priced products"	74.8%
remove clumps "the mascara can come out quite thick and clumpy though so i usually use a clean eye lash wand to separate the lashes and remove clumps after putting it on"	74.8%
seems very "am usually a big fan of maybelline but this mascara seems very dry in the tube definitely not very black and clumps easily"	74.8%
losing lashes "it is easily removed without losing lashes either using makeup remover or wipes"	74.8%
looks crap "firstly its disgusting that it didnt come sealed and secondly it's so clumpy it looks crap"	74.7%
black mess "made all of my eyelashes stick together in one big black mess"	74.7%
very fussy "due to my personal experience i would not recommend this mascara or buy it again but based on other reviews i might be very fussy as many people praise it"	74.7%
wouldnt order "my wife loves this mascara she orders it all the time and she wouldnt order any other she said it’s the best for making her lashes look nice and separate and lasts well without drying out and when it gets old it don’t get clumpy"	74.6%
leaves smudges "the only comolate that i have is that it leaves smudges under my eyes throughout the day but i haven't found a mascara that doesn't do this"	74.4%
everything l need "it does everything l need"	74.4%
look nasty "its awful clumpy and makes my lashes look nasty !"	74.0%
infection risk "as it is intended for use on the eyes this poses an infection risk and is not acceptable"	73.2%
wasted my money "i only wish i never wasted my money on the more expensive brands"	72.9%
clumpy & tight "not for me goes sticky & makes lashes feel clumpy & tight there for making lash’s sore"	72.2%
become very thin "my eyelashes have fallen out and become very thin because of this mascara"	69.6%
very weird "very weird even with several coats still looks like you are wearing no mascara"	69.5%
other wipes "i've used other wipes but not as effective"	69.4%
much higher "this stuff lengthens and thickens to make it look like you are wearing fake lashes it gives me the same effect as much higher priced products"	69.1%
little sellotape "this item came unsealed just a little sellotape!"	69.1%
return window "i contacted the seller about this on the final day of my return window i forgot until that point and they asked for my customer number i gave them this and they haven't replied since"	68.5%
threw it away "i threw it away"	67.6%
smudge easy "does not smudge easy to apply"	67.6%
difficult to remove "moreover it is extremely difficult to remove i lose a couple of eyelashes every time!"	67.2%
not bring it home "i had bought maybelline waterproof mascara for a holiday and did not bring it home"	67.1%
unhappy with this "very unhappy with this"	67.0%
nearly empty "100% the mascara as over a week the days i’ve reverted to my nearly empty old one i’ve been fine"	66.9%
unsure about using "it didn't have a seal so i was unsure about using it but had immediate refund with no fuss and will order another"	66.0%
remove from lashes "hard to remove from lashes"	65.8%
it's discontinued "i will riot in the streets if it’s discontinued"	65.8%
short multiple strokes "the way i apply in short multiple strokes makes my lashes look thick and long"	65.8%
leaves no clumps "the formula is rich and thick brushes through easily and leaves no clumps even after several coats"	65.7%
dreadful clumpy "i read the reviews and was impressed but what i got was dreadful clumpy could not separate lashes and so difficult to remove"	65.4%
sore on my lashes "it makes my lashes stick together and when i tried to remove it it won’t come off and actually feels sore on my lashes"	65.4%
nothing special "i'd recommend it it was nothing special but neither are my makeup skills so maybe in the hands of someone who regularly glams up it would be a more remarkable product"	65.3%
waste of money and time "waste of money and time"	64.7%
loose inside a parcel "but this was just loose inside a parcel box and has no seal on it so anyone could have used it!"	64.7%
cheap price "cheap price gives eye lashes such a full non clumped look"	64.7%
much on the brush "even then it goes on unevenly and clumpy with still too much on the brush"	64.7%
immediate refund "it didn't have a seal so i was unsure about using it but had immediate refund with no fuss and will order another"	64.4%
leaks within minutes "this leaks within minutes goes on well but i look like a panda within 30 min"	64.3%
does n't do this "the only comolate that i have is that it leaves smudges under my eyes throughout the day but i haven't found a mascara that doesn't do this"	64.3%
almost dried "eventually arrived but is almost dried up"	64.3%
tacky to apply "however after a while it seems to dry up a little and even with the fine brush becomes quite clumpy tacky to apply and sticks my lashes together"	64.3%
disappointed with "i bought this mascara several times in the raw and i haven't been disappointed with it"	64.1%
slides off in clumps "doesn't dry 100% doesn't stick to your lashes and just slides off in clumps"	63.2%
mascara junkie "i'm a mascara junkie and have tried most brands and this is better than a lot of the bigger more expensive brands"	63.0%
much mascara "hard to not have too much mascara on the wand"	62.7%
with wipes "comes off easily with wipes"	62.6%
broken straight away "my phone has fallen on the floor once and not even from a big height and the case itself got broken straight away"	62.6%
little cheaper "i decided to purchase online as its a little cheaper"	61.0%
getting expensive "used maybelline products most of the time but getting expensive in the shops"	61.0%
long lashes "last long lashes look naturally long"	61.0%
were damaged "i've ordered this mascara before and liked it however this time around the bristles on the mascara were damaged and missing!"	60.9%
other mascaras "and it doesnt make my eyes water like alot of other mascaras it doesnt even feel like i'm wearing mascara"	60.6%
dont remove "basically it stays exactly the same until you dont remove it"	60.5%
logged up my lashes "it clumped and logged up my lashes"	60.4%
smudges easily "smudges easily"	60.3%
itchy sore eyes "used it as i needed it had awful itchy sore eyes for days afterward"	60.1%
short lashes "i am a girl with dead straight short lashes"	59.7%
take time to remove "it take time to remove it"	58.8%
gets clumpy "it soon gets clumpy on the eye lashes but i am content just to be able to sort out my eyebrows"	58.2%
does not clump "easy to apply does not clump and it is not too 'wet'"	57.9%
sparse and short "it does absolutely nothing for my eyelashes and makes them look so sparse and short"	57.7%
first to complain "the response suggested that i wasn't the first to complain"	57.6%
it's not waterproof "even though it's not waterproof it's test proof"	57.6%
would n't buy again "i think this product is fake i wouldn't buy again"	57.6%
it not being sealed "i’m furious with the purchase and will not be ordering it again all due to it not being sealed"	57.6%
would n't order it again "really disappointed with this mascara it’s really clumpy already and i wouldn’t order it again"	57.5%
mascara was quite "the mascara was quite dry"	57.3%
lashes are stiff "almost impossible to apply a second coat after first has dried because lashes are stiff"	57.0%
eyelashes falling "however as with all other waterproof mascaras the process of removal with wipes results in my eyelashes falling out but this is probably more my rubbish eyelash's problem than the mascara's!"	57.0%
false lash effect "it has a false lash effect"	56.8%
flick dry flakes "i tried to remove some of it by running it over the top of the bottle as you do but all it did was flick dry flakes everywhere"	56.5%
late and not taken "i've had times where i've gone to bed late and not taken my make up off got up and my eyelashes are still perfect!"	56.5%
hardly write reviews "i hardly write reviews!"	56.4%
no security sticker "there was no security sticker over the lid"	56.4%
would n't recommend "i wouldn't recommend it"	56.4%
mascara is awful "this mascara is awful"	56.3%
been left to dry "i suspect the item is either used or has been left to dry out"	56.2%
clog easily "however it does not seem to clog easily"	55.8%
previously unscrewed "there is no way to tell if this product was previously unscrewed and openned"	55.3%
it's ridiculous "it's ridiculous"	55.3%
money sore eyes "waste of money sore eyes !"	55.2%
suffer terribly "water doesn't seem to budge it but i do suffer terribly with panda eyes and although this isn't the worst one i've used that does it i can't just apply then forget about it"	55.2%
what i do n't like "what i don't like is the shape of the bottle and especially the lid"	55.2%
does n't give me allergy "it's the only mascara that i feel good in sleeping and waking up beautiful next day and the only one what doesn't give me allergy"	55.1%
might smudge a "awesome mascara for the price point but it might smudge a bit"	55.0%
it's the worst "but please don’t buy this mascara it’s the worst !"	54.9%
just not hygenic "it could have been used previously its just not hygenic"	54.9%
which is a pity "there is no option to return which is a pity"	54.9%
volume but not clumpy "lashes are lighted with volume but not clumpy"	54.7%
longer and thicker "lashes look longer and thicker without needing loads of coats"	54.7%
n't look like "no but i also didn't look like i was trying out for panda school so its a win for me"	54.7%
does n't go crunchy "but it doesn't clump holds a curl while looking natural doesn't go crunchy removes easily"	54.7%
would not buy again "not that impressed would not buy again"	54.7%
not on this product "disappointed that the hygiene seal is not on this product"	54.7%
will never buy it again "i will never buy it again"	54.7%
little ott for daywear "i think this is good for evening makeup but a little ott for daywear"	54.7%
wrong with this "i've tried many mascaras and there are better high end mascaras but on a tight budget you can't go wrong with this one"	54.7%
n't like this mascara "i really don’t like this mascara"	54.7%
n't be opened previously "i wouldn't purchase again as i can't be sure it's new and hasn't be opened previously"	54.7%
arrived not sealed "product arrived not sealed!"	54.7%
n't buy this mascara "but please don’t buy this mascara it’s the worst !"	54.7%
does not apply evenly "it also does not apply evenly"	54.6%
compared to my usual "like the style of the wand compared to my usual"	54.6%
drop of water "for the name you'd expect quality but this was so dry and hardly any product in it at all even when i added a drop of water there was nothing"	54.6%
unsafe and unacceptable "this is completely unsafe and unacceptable for consumer use"	54.6%
not come sealed though "it did not come sealed though"	54.6%
does n't go on clumpy "makes my lashes look a lot longer than they already are and product doesn't go on clumpy"	54.5%
not in this life "but not in this life"	54.5%
will not buy again "will not buy again"	54.5%
reccomend and wont "don't reccomend and wont be buying again!"	54.4%
hard to remove "had gone thick and clumpy hard to remove too"	54.4%
with this mascara "love this mascara i wear contact lenses and my eyes get quite easily irritated but not with this mascara and it really opens your eyes up and makes my lashes look a lot thicker than they actually are it is also really easy it remove with a baby wipe this is a make up bag essential"	54.4%
wet not even clumpy "just so wet not even clumpy but just so thin and watery that it makes your lashes look like 3 spider legs"	54.2%
last very long "the only downfall is that the tube doesn't last very long"	54.0%
lashes very long "but does make lashes very long and doesn't smudge and only caused one small bit to fall onto skin"	54.0%
not huge or volumed "my lashes are not huge or volumed but with this mascara it looks like i have only 3 5 of them"	53.9%
came without protection "came without protection which means it could’ve been opened before and used or refilled changed ink"	53.9%
has been unused "usually a mascara should come sealed so the consumer is confident that it has been unused"	53.7%
make a mess "the only problem about this is it can make a mess because it’s too much on the brush"	53.7%
absolutely unacceptable "i have just asked for a refund this is absolutely unacceptable"	53.6%
looks quite old and "not amazing cheaper than in store but looks quite old and dry"	53.6%
that it was n't right "it didn’t arrive with any sealed packaging around the top like when you buy from a shop i should of known then that it wasn’t right"	53.5%
just water "needs make up remover to shift not just water"	53.5%
it's been binned "how unhygienic and a total waste of money as i don’t trust to you use it so it’s been binned"	53.5%
unevenly and clumpy "even then it goes on unevenly and clumpy with still too much on the brush"	53.5%
nothing compared to this "i’ve had 2 other more expensive mascaras before this one and they’re nothing compared to this"	53.4%
wearing no mascara "very weird even with several coats still looks like you are wearing no mascara"	53.4%
there is no seal "there is no seal?"	53.4%
flake it lasts all "it doesn't flake it lasts all day and you don't get panda eyes after 12 hours even with an oily complexion "	53.3%
minimal transfer "when i woke my eyes there's minimal transfer to finger tissue"	53.3%
smudges under the eyes "may be waterproof but it smudges under the eyes even in only the top lashes have been coated"	53.2%
there was nothing "for the name you'd expect quality but this was so dry and hardly any product in it at all even when i added a drop of water there was nothing"	53.2%
n't even sealed "so it was delivered and to my shock it wasn't even sealed!"	53.2%
did n't look used "the product was not sealed at all and although from the outside it didn’t look used"	53.2%
leaves lumps "the lashes are sticking together the mascara is chunky and leaves lumps"	52.9%
stained around my eyes "it is stained around my eyes by the end of each day and if i get stuck in the rain or shed a tear it runs everywhere!"	52.9%
work sometimes "water needs adding to thin it out and even that doesn't work sometimes"	52.9%
with no clumping "applies evenly with no clumping and makes my eyelashes stand out"	52.7%
extremly fregile "on the otherside it is extremly fregile"	52.7%
barely noticeable "i’ve got really short eyelashes which are barely noticeable"	52.7%
worst i 've ever "horrible mascara the worst i've ever had!"	52.6%
look gaudy "plus the champagne light pink colour of the tube doesn't look gaudy"	52.6%
remove some of "i tried to remove some of it by running it over the top of the bottle as you do but all it did was flick dry flakes everywhere"	52.5%
going down slides "even after going down slides"	52.5%
would n't buy this again "i wouldn't buy this again"	52.5%
giving 2stars "just received and have not tried it yet but the only reason i’m giving 2stars is because the seal was open so i don’t really trust if something has been mixed not it or not!"	52.4%
have no idea "the mascara isnt sealed we have no idea if the eye infection was related but we won't be buying again"	52.2%
full non clumped look "cheap price gives eye lashes such a full non clumped look"	51.8%
brush is not good "this mascara makes my lashes very clumpy the brush is not good"	51.7%
short stumpy lashes "i have short stumpy lashes and after spending years trying lots of high end and drugstore mascaras i have finally found one that lengthens and curls my lashes"	51.5%
short stubby lashes "having short stubby lashes which are prone to falling out when using mascara i am always wary of using waterproof mascaras"	51.5%
n't curl my lashes "i don't curl my lashes and they look good with this on em"	51.4%
really short eyelashes "i’ve got really short eyelashes which are barely noticeable"	51.3%
plastic sealant "it doesn’t come with plastic sealant like it does in superdrug’s boots etc"	51.2%
would not recommend "would not recommend"	50.8%
securely sealed "why would i want to put something on my eyelashes when its not securely sealed"	50.7%
tamper seal "when ever i’ve bought mascara it’s always been wrapped in a tamper seal of some sort or in a box"	50.6%
taken me 3 days "it’s taken me 3 days to remove it from my eyelashes and it’s pulled eyelashes out!"	50.5%
have n't replied since "i contacted the seller about this on the final day of my return window i forgot until that point and they asked for my customer number i gave them this and they haven't replied since"	50.4%
worst mascara ever "the worst mascara ever!"	50.2%
...

Cons [108] of Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid E..	Strength
complete waste in both products "a complete waste of money for me and will be going back to the good old maybelline that stays where it should do"	99.9%
total waste in both products "total waste of money!"	99.8%
very disappointed in both products "very disappointed"	99.0%
only problem in both products "it lasts you can sleep with it the only problem for me is the thickness it is very thin produces thin lines and i like a thicker line just means more drawing but i highly recommend this product"	74.5%
black smudges in both products "i bought this specifically to try a non smudging liquid eyeliner and was so disappointed that i will never use it again having tried it twice with no other make up then with primer it smudged and was actually sticky on my eyelids leaving embarrassing black smudges throughout the day"	74.3%
waste of money in both products "a waste of money"	52.2%
feels horrible "the eye liner feels horrible like wearing plastic"	99.7%
fall asleep "for me this is the only eyeliner i've found that doesn't give panda eyes not even the next morning if you accidentally fall asleep with your make up on"	99.7%
nope terrible "so nope terrible buy and i got both the black and brown so double the waste of money"	97.5%
totally cheap "totally cheap formula i’ll be returning all 4 of these"	88.3%
looked awful "it then disintegrated during the day leaving patchy residue all over my eye lid which looked awful"	87.7%
worst example "possibly the worst example of an eyeliner pen ever"	85.9%
smudging down "this usually spells disaster with any other eyeliners because it usually starts smudging down the corners of my eyes very quickly"	75.0%
pricey liner "this is crucial because it's a relatively speaking pricey liner and yet has an obviously really limited amount of actual product in it"	74.9%
sadly discontinued "looking to replace the now sadly discontinued excellent estée lauder zero smudge liner"	74.9%
only issue "the only issue i have with it is it slightly gets rubbed off when i use my eyelash curler sometimes a bit comes off with it"	74.9%
smudge liner "looking to replace the now sadly discontinued excellent estée lauder zero smudge liner"	74.8%
over hyped "won't be buying from them again however as i suspect they're over hyped"	74.8%
supposedly waterproof "that was a supposedly waterproof liquid eyeliner"	74.8%
does n't work "my eyeliner doesn’t work"	74.8%
being fake "as for being fake if it is it's a very good copy"	74.7%
cheap product "easy to use but not waterproof disappointing cheap product rimmel pencil last longer what a shame!"	74.5%
strangely sticky "i've found this eye liner strangely sticky and does transfer to the top of my eye lids throughout the day"	74.5%
defo buying "defo buying it again when mine runs out"	74.4%
cheap ones "did not last any longer than the cheap ones i have bought"	74.3%
less opaque "however after some use the nib becomes worn and harder to work product dries out and becomes less opaque"	74.2%
virtually impossible "it bleeds into the lines on my skin also so i found it virtually impossible to create a nice sharp cat eye"	74.2%
very watery "i have very watery eyes and oily eyelids and many other eyeliners either smudge into my crease or are rubbed away by my watery eyes i am extremely surprised after 6 hrs it hasn’t budged apart from a tiny bit from being rubbed away from tears from hay fever"	74.0%
pricey eyeliner "bought to replace another pricey eyeliner this sounded perfect"	73.9%
drying hence "it does however tend to fade in some spots over the day or while it's drying hence the four star review"	73.7%
impending eyelits "i have impending eyelits and for me this is great find because the color is not spread out at all"	73.4%
waste money "used it twice and now think why waste money on items like this when i can just gouge out my eye ball and replace it with stones"	73.1%
impossible to wear "it dries sticky and transfers everywhere so it's pretty much impossible to wear"	72.5%
patchy residue "it then disintegrated during the day leaving patchy residue all over my eye lid which looked awful"	72.5%
only negative "the only negative is that because it's so waterproof it doesn't want to come off i use the type of eye makeup remover that you have to shake with the oil layer and it comes off a treat with that"	72.3%
wear eyeliner "stays put doesn't run or smudge and does a lovely line either thick or thin whatever i choose now i wear eyeliner with confidence that i won't have black runs at the sides of my eyes now!"	71.5%
loses intensity "the line around the eye stays longer but also loses intensity in color"	71.3%
sugar paper "similar to an old marker pen also bleeds like ink on sugar paper"	69.7%
budged apart "i have very watery eyes and oily eyelids and many other eyeliners either smudge into my crease or are rubbed away by my watery eyes i am extremely surprised after 6 hrs it hasn’t budged apart from a tiny bit from being rubbed away from tears from hay fever"	69.6%
waste your money "not good don't waste your money"	68.1%
waste time "i'd recommend anyone to not waste time with this one and order the tattoo liner straight ahead it is the best and vegan!"	67.9%
lacks pigmentation "it lacks pigmentation and is pretty shiny which i personally don't like in an eyeliner"	67.3%
not water proof "it was not water proof but it was a very rich black only positive thing i can say about it"	67.3%
dont llke the line "at the same time i dont llke the line to be too harsh which is why i bought it in grey rather than black"	66.4%
no extra amount "first off it has no extra amount as is usual with pens of this amount"	66.0%
never again "never again"	65.9%
drenched in the rain "been drenched in the rain and also stays fine"	64.7%
bleed when applied "long lasting doesn’t bleed when applied so leaves a nice smooth line"	64.2%
unjustified piece "this way i wont have to pay £16 on this piece of unjustified piece of you know what"	63.1%
leaves a smudge "i also use the l'oréal one but after awhile it leaves a smudge under my eye from blinking and the stila one stays in place"	63.0%
rather slitty "i'm chinese so i have rather slitty eyes"	62.9%
rather windy "once came in from a rather windy break duty i'm a teacher to be told by a student that my eyeliner was 'a bit weird'"	62.9%
obviously really limited "this is crucial because it's a relatively speaking pricey liner and yet has an obviously really limited amount of actual product in it"	62.3%
does n't even "it doesn't even last an hour without half coming off"	61.5%
fault amazon "can’t fault amazon at all as always great speedy prime service"	60.5%
experience with eyeliners "highly recommended from a person having bad experience with eyeliners in the past!"	60.3%
smudges or fades a "it doesn't stay all day if my eyes water in the cold i find it smudges or fades a bit"	59.9%
funeral plenty "wore this eyeliner for my dads funeral plenty of tears but eyeliner stayed put"	59.4%
smudge proof eyeliner "i'm planning on going back to my cheaper but completely smudge proof eyeliner very soon"	59.1%
painful search "the painful search continues : fed up of these companies discontinuing amazing products"	59.0%
stay on at all smudged "the grey one didn’t stay on at all smudged"	58.1%
liquid eyeliner "i have over laying eyelids and struggle always to find a liquid eyeliner that hasn't disappeared by the end of the day"	57.6%
liquid liners "after years of preferring liquid liners i now prefer this felt pen"	57.6%
liquid linter "i recommend nyx matt liquid linter if you want something that doesn't budge"	57.6%
matte liquid liner "i returned the product and found a good replacement nyx matte liquid liner which does the job for me and is much cheaper for more product"	57.4%
from hay fever "i have very watery eyes and oily eyelids and many other eyeliners either smudge into my crease or are rubbed away by my watery eyes i am extremely surprised after 6 hrs it hasn’t budged apart from a tiny bit from being rubbed away from tears from hay fever"	57.2%
might be fake "i was hesitant however that it might be fake but purchased it anyways"	57.0%
n't last long "this is buy far the best the only one that claim close was smashbox down side with smashboc it didn't last long"	56.8%
enough liquid "not enough liquid"	56.4%
hard to go wrong "i am absolutely useless with liquid eyeliner but with this it's hard to go wrong!"	56.3%
even more mess "the smudge is then difficult to remove without making even more mess!"	56.3%
that does n't budge "i recommend nyx matt liquid linter if you want something that doesn't budge"	56.2%
eyeliner goes nowhere "this eyeliner goes nowhere!"	56.0%
this problem "i've always had this problem with all eyeliners however and i think this is because i tend to touch and dab my eyes quite frequently"	55.3%
few times useless "this matters too because applying it then requires going over a few times useless when you want a flicked eye as it just keeps building up product and ruining the effect "	55.1%
making a bid for freedom "no sooner was it on & i turned away from the mirror than it was making a bid for freedom"	55.0%
have dry skin "i have dry skin and have tried this with and without primer and get the same results"	54.9%
would not purchase again "would not purchase again"	54.7%
does not last the "this is disappointing is not waterproof and does not last the day"	54.7%
up fast this "whilst most eyeliner pens dry up fast this one lasts weeks months before you need to replace it"	54.7%
load of rubbish "do not waste your money barely there doesn't last and made my eyes water expensive for a load of rubbish"	54.6%
look like crap "makes all my other ones look like crap what the hell was i doing before this was in my life walking around like some sort of smudge monster"	54.6%
n't like this product "i didn't like this product"	54.5%
does not pull at eyelids "brush is soft and workable does not pull at eyelids"	54.5%
would n't recomment "might work for a twenty something but for a +35 year old i wouldn't recomment it"	54.5%
failed to impress "had high expectations of this product but it failed to impress me"	54.3%
exract te lgd withn "you need to shakeit to exract te lgd withn the pen"	54.3%
have never had an issue "hi i have been using stilla eye liner for years and have never had an issue"	53.9%
very difficult to "i have been using macs waterproof eyeliner which is very difficult to use but really stays on all day its the same in the evening as when you put it on in the morning"	53.7%
then this is n't "if you are looking for a waterproof eyeliner then this isn't it"	53.7%
bleeds into the lines "it bleeds into the lines on my skin also so i found it virtually impossible to create a nice sharp cat eye"	53.6%
smudge into my crease "i have very watery eyes and oily eyelids and many other eyeliners either smudge into my crease or are rubbed away by my watery eyes i am extremely surprised after 6 hrs it hasn’t budged apart from a tiny bit from being rubbed away from tears from hay fever"	53.5%
very much product "leaves not very much product on your eyelid"	53.2%
n't ever discontinue "please don't ever discontinue"	53.2%
very greasy "my eyelids are very greasy and i've been struggling to find an eyeliner which stays on my lids all day"	53.0%
photos of my old eyeliner "see photos of my old eyeliner and the new one i bought here"	52.1%
not completely waterproof "however it’s not completely waterproof sadly!"	52.1%
does n't budge "i wholly recommend this to any eyeliner enthusiast or the odd dabbler i even tried rubbing it and it doesn't budge!"	52.1%
smashbox down "this is buy far the best the only one that claim close was smashbox down side with smashboc it didn't last long"	52.1%
****** sh*t "f****** sh*t!"	52.0%
costs far less "i have been using chanel liquid eye liner for years but this is pretty much the same and costs far less"	51.5%
smudged on my upper "it smudged on my upper lid"	51.4%
that does n't move "if anyone has any suggestions to a similar eyeliner that doesn’t move"	51.3%
apply but did not last "it is easy to apply but did not last"	51.0%
have my doubts "i have my doubts whether this product is genuine"	51.0%
quick dry liner "this is an easy glide quick dry liner that stays in place with no smudges feathering or running"	50.9%
almost dry pencil "can't use it as it came almost dry pencil"	50.8%
trouble started "and then the trouble started"	50.2%
...

Pros [197] of Lash Sensational Volumizing and Thicke..	Strength
absolutely brilliant in both products "i've tried a lot of mascaras in search of the perfect one over the years and this is absolutely brilliant!"	100.0%
excellent product in both products "excellent product"	100.0%
very pleased in both products "it’s also the kind of mascara that doesn’t damage my lashes if i curl them after 2 coats so i’m very pleased"	100.0%
highly recommend in both products "highly recommend"	99.6%
really good in both products "it has really good coverage but it's hard to remove which makes it super water resistant"	99.3%
best results in both products "it gets every lash for best results use eyelashe curlers first"	99.3%
genuine item in both products "genuine item and arrived sealed"	75.0%
works well in both products "it has a relatively wet formula which works well to lengthen and volumize lashes"	75.0%
good price in both products "i love this mascara glad to find at such a good price as often near £9"	75.0%
great price in both products "long lasting throughout the day and for great price"	75.0%
looks great in both products "eyes feels great and looks great!"	74.8%
waterproof mascara in both products "but it's a waterproof mascara and stays on well for a long time"	74.8%
very quickly in both products "arrived very quickly much earlier than estimated"	74.8%
good value in both products "prompt delivery would buy again good value for money"	74.3%
does n't smudge in both products "it gives great length and volume and doesn't smudge"	74.2%
really nice in both products "really nice mascara don't really need a lot to get the full effect not too clumpy and a decent price"	74.2%
perfect product in both products "perfect product"	74.1%
very happy in both products "very happy"	74.0%
lasting and good in both products "great mascara long lasting and good value for money"	73.8%
good product in both products "good product well made and recommended"	73.7%
staying power in both products "overall a very good mascara with serious staying power"	73.4%
nice product in both products "nice product"	73.4%
good quality in both products "good quality"	73.3%
great reviews in both products "i brought it because it has great reviews and is great catches all my lashes no clamps i kept searching for mascara i will like for years and this is definitely the one"	73.2%
highly recommended in both products "highly recommended!"	72.6%
would recommend in both products "i would recommend"	72.4%
much better in both products "would recommend to anyone looking for a good high street mascara much better than any others in this price range that i’ve tried"	71.9%
buying again in both products "will definitely be buying again"	71.2%
worth the money in both products "worth the money"	68.4%
absolutely gorgeous "absolutely gorgeous mascara brilliant promotes longer lashes"	100.0%
genuine product "very nice genuine product"	99.9%
brilliant product "brilliant product!"	99.9%
finest eyelashes "the brush is the key it coats the finest eyelashes and separates and lengthens them"	99.8%
lovely full "my favourite mascara build up in layers for a lovely full lash effect"	99.6%
best thing "the best thing was that despite this not being a waterproof mascara it was still very much in evidence after a day at work which is usually unheard of for me!"	99.6%
lovely beautiful "lovely beautiful eye lashes"	99.3%
amazing product "amazing product for the cheap price!"	98.5%
fantastic bargain "at this price had to be a fantastic bargain"	98.3%
great consistency "great consistency"	98.2%
genuine article "not the genuine article as it caused redness and swelling of my eyelids which does not happen with the genuine product"	98.0%
very natural "very natural looking product when applied"	96.8%
good colour "good colour stays all day"	96.3%
fine eyelashes "this mascara made my very pale fine eyelashes look dark and well defined"	95.9%
nice eyelashes "seems to give me nice eyelashes"	95.9%
well throughout "stays on well throughout the day"	95.9%
super lashes "super lashes!"	95.6%
love love love "love love love!"	93.1%
fantastic and great "looks fantastic and great price"	93.1%
really amazing "but really amazing!"	93.0%
brilliant coverage "gives brilliant coverage and makes lashes look thick and long"	92.7%
before but loved "never used curved before but loved it"	91.7%
mascara is brilliant "this mascara is brilliant"	90.3%
huge and beautiful "one stroke and ur lashes are huge and beautiful"	90.0%
beauty bloggers "honestly if you haven't tried this yet give it a go it's a big hit on youtube and with beauty bloggers too and it really does live up to the hype"	89.4%
mascara brilliant "absolutely gorgeous mascara brilliant promotes longer lashes"	88.9%
good valuel "bought before would buy again and good valuel"	88.8%
good mascar "very very good mascar"	88.8%
found this "having tried several makes of mascara over the years i finally found this gem"	88.3%
great applicator "great applicator and the mascara really does make lashes appear longer love it"	88.0%
well coated "this mascara is amazing for the price my long lashes were well coated and full of volume when applied"	87.7%
look great "lasts all day and look great"	75.0%
perfect mascara "off with no effort when removing won't need to keep looking for the perfect mascara and will buy this over and over again"	75.0%
good coverage "gives a good coverage and would order again"	75.0%
looks amazing "looks amazing adds volume and length and never looks clumpy"	75.0%
great brush "great brush on this"	75.0%
swift delivery "swift delivery"	75.0%
uniquely shaped "its uniquely shaped brush is perfect for achieving a full and voluminous look"	75.0%
nice mascara "nice mascara"	75.0%
best price "best mascara i've used in ages for the best price!"	75.0%
nice brush "nice brush that has two curves for applying to lashes without getting all over your face"	75.0%
great mascara "great mascara"	75.0%
looks good "easy to use and lasts all day looks good when on"	75.0%
great value "great value for money as well!"	74.9%
decent price "really nice mascara don't really need a lot to get the full effect not too clumpy and a decent price"	74.9%
really quick "arrived really quick and a great mascara"	74.9%
fast delivery "good mascara fast delivery"	74.9%
good reviews "so having read all the good reviews on here decided to purchase this"	74.9%
nice effect "and nice effect!"	74.9%
premium brands "i've been trying premium brands for years and shopping in department stores but this is my fave by far!"	74.9%
ordering again "really nice mascara not clumpy brush is perfect will definetly be ordering again"	74.8%
lasting power "in terms of lasting power my lashes stay looking great for around 12 hours and when it comes to removing it i’ve found it can be done beat using an oil based eye make up remover"	74.8%
decent amount "it gives my lashes a decent amount of volume and also gives it a lot of length"	74.8%
feels great "eyes feels great and looks great!"	74.8%
pretty looking "pretty looking shell !"	74.8%
budget friendly "my favourite mascara hands down the best budget friendly and great quality mascara"	74.8%
really showcase "this product however gives my lashes definition and enhances them to really showcase how long and full they are"	74.8%
nice black colour "nice black colour and makes lashes look fuller and longer"	74.8%
price range "would recommend to anyone looking for a good high street mascara much better than any others in this price range that i’ve tried"	74.8%
looking great "in terms of lasting power my lashes stay looking great for around 12 hours and when it comes to removing it i’ve found it can be done beat using an oil based eye make up remover"	74.7%
positive reviews "bought this diebtonall of the positive reviews on here"	74.6%
life saver "im obsessed with this mascara literally a life saver i never really realise how long it makes my lashes look until i run out and in desperation end up having to leave it in hot water to actually be able to get the last of the product out until im able to order a new one 😂"	74.6%
lovely mascara "lovely mascara and good value for money"	74.6%
amazing mascara "this is such an amazing mascara that not only provides volume but also length"	74.5%
pretty nice "at first it is pretty nice to use"	74.5%
doesnt smudge "really dark doesnt smudge when it rains and i work outside!"	74.5%
good choice "a good choice for inexpensive mascara"	74.5%
fantastic item "fantastic item"	74.5%
fabulous non smudge "fabulous non smudge"	74.5%
really lasts "eyelashes look fab and it really lasts"	74.5%
amazing delivery "amazing delivery !"	74.5%
excellent value "excellent value and fast shipping"	74.4%
loves this "my partner loves this as does what it says"	74.4%
love maybelline mascara "i love maybelline mascara as i seem to be allergic to many other makes"	74.3%
great drugstore option "i love this mascara great drugstore option!"	74.3%
lasting properties "i love this mascara for its lasting properties!"	74.3%
best mascara "was a bit sceptical of ordering this but i'm so glad i did the brush is excellent quality and the mascara is amazing together it makes the best mascara i've ever used giving me eye lashes such a full non clumped look"	74.3%
fast shipping "fast shipping"	74.2%
awesome mascara "awesome mascara!"	74.1%
very waterproof "separates the lashes very well and looks gorgeous very waterproof and a lot cheaper on amazon than in the shops defo recommend !"	74.1%
favourite part "the brush is my favourite part"	74.1%
being honest "good coverage & dark black reasonable value but probably would not rush to buy this product again if i'm being honest"	74.1%
favourite mascara "my favourite mascara"	74.0%
waterproof version "i will be ordering the waterproof version now"	74.0%
being waterproof "goes on well true to being waterproof"	73.9%
extremely waterproof "doesn’t clump the lashes together and is extremely waterproof"	73.9%
very luscious "it is non sticky and literally glides on leaving a very luscious lengthening effect"	73.9%
excellent service "this product is my favourite and the only one i use excellent service excellent delivery brilliant value"	73.9%
excellent mascara "i did go and buy a new one on the high street and it is an excellent mascara"	73.9%
good thing "the mascara tube came packaged in plastic wrapping which is always a good thing :"	73.9%
ordering this "was a bit sceptical of ordering this but i'm so glad i did the brush is excellent quality and the mascara is amazing together it makes the best mascara i've ever used giving me eye lashes such a full non clumped look"	73.9%
lovely and firm "the brush is lovely and firm which fans out lashes beautifully"	73.9%
receive compliments "the only mascara i use and always receive compliments on my lashes"	73.8%
reasonably priced "for such a reasonably priced mascara in comparison to the high end rivals this product is incredible"	73.8%
happy thanks "happy thanks"	73.8%
hygiene seal "arrived without a hygiene seal"	73.7%
looked amazing "the product made my lashes look voluminous and they were curled up and looked amazing!"	73.7%
greater effect "i double the layers for greater effect"	73.7%
longer love "great applicator and the mascara really does make lashes appear longer love it"	73.7%
truly waterproof "adds length volume & is truly waterproof just what i need as my eyes water alot"	73.7%
looks gorgeous "separates the lashes very well and looks gorgeous very waterproof and a lot cheaper on amazon than in the shops defo recommend !"	73.6%
look fantastic "after using it this morning i have to agree my lashes look fantastic really full no smudging and very noticeable!"	73.6%
hardest person "i was getting a new mascara for my mum to see what she thought of it and to her surprise she is really liking it and she is the hardest person to get to change her mascara!"	73.6%
relatively easily "it removes relatively easily too"	73.5%
spider legs lashes "brilliant mascara that adds volume and length without leading to the dreaded clumped up spider legs lashes"	73.5%
effective necessity "oil based remover an effective necessity"	73.5%
dries nicely "however after a few uses the mascara dries nicely and it becomes even more pleasant to use"	73.4%
look super "separates each lash and makes them look super long and thick"	73.4%
relatively quickly "dries relatively quickly curls well and lasts a long time"	73.4%
numerous times "love this mascara have bought it numerous times"	73.3%
ingenious design "ingenious design of brush the best product for me"	73.1%
plastic wrapping "the mascara tube came packaged in plastic wrapping which is always a good thing :"	73.1%
excellent price "wow this is a great mascara no clumping easy to apply and excellent price"	73.0%
brilliant brush "brilliant brush"	73.0%
lovely product "lovely product and it lasted for long time"	72.9%
spider legs "the length is amazing it doesn't look clumpy or like spider legs and they don't drop"	72.9%
amazing together "was a bit sceptical of ordering this but i'm so glad i did the brush is excellent quality and the mascara is amazing together it makes the best mascara i've ever used giving me eye lashes such a full non clumped look"	72.8%
amazing makes "amazing makes your eyelashes look very bold and noticeable"	72.8%
fantastic mascara "a fantastic mascara for your money in line with the high end alternatives"	72.7%
definitely recommend "definitely recommend"	72.7%
high enough "seriously i can't rate this high enough separates lashes goes on easily and lasts"	72.5%
good mascara "good mascara"	72.5%
does n't flake "it volumises the lashes and doesn’t flake"	72.5%
were popular "i have always loved maybelline since my teen days when the original green and pink container were popular"	72.3%
lashes beautifully "the brush is lovely and firm which fans out lashes beautifully"	72.2%
promotes longer "absolutely gorgeous mascara brilliant promotes longer lashes"	72.1%
daughter delighted "daughter delighted"	72.0%
maybeline great "i prefer maybeline great lash but gave this one a try for a change"	71.9%
good things "bought this after reading some good things in newspaper about how people were calling this the holy grail of mascaras"	71.9%
smoothly and looks "glides on smoothly and looks professional"	71.7%
order again "will definitely order again"	71.4%
definitely worth trying "definitely worth trying"	71.4%
always runs "my mascara always runs"	71.2%
lash enhancement "however also givesnice smdivided even length lash enhancement"	71.1%
curls well "dries relatively quickly curls well and lasts a long time"	71.1%
recommend this "fab in every way would definitely recommend this"	70.9%
something quick "i bought as it was cheap and needed something quick"	70.9%
tried good "one of the best mascara i have tried good if your lashes are fine like mine"	70.7%
prompt delivery "prompt delivery would buy again good value for money"	70.7%
happy girl "happy girl"	70.6%
everyone says "it is as good as everyone says!"	70.4%
coverage spread length "great coverage spread length and curl of lashes and can get into all the corners and individual lashes without blobs overloading lashes"	70.4%
thank you received "thank you received my black mascara and love it would definitely recommend it :"	70.1%
adds volume and length "looks amazing adds volume and length and never looks clumpy"	70.1%
well defined "this mascara made my very pale fine eyelashes look dark and well defined"	69.7%
best mascaras "glad i did possibly bone of the best mascaras i have used"	69.1%
great catches "i brought it because it has great reviews and is great catches all my lashes no clamps i kept searching for mascara i will like for years and this is definitely the one"	69.1%
lush afterwards "the black is intense and lashes feel just as lush afterwards"	69.0%
just fab eyelashes "this mascara is perfect no mess just fab eyelashes"	69.0%
pretty water "it stays on all day is pretty water cry proof and gives a dramatic lash effect!"	68.9%
lashes naturally "love this mascara i have long thick eye lashes naturally and this makes them look fab!"	68.6%
fits the bill "tried many mascaras over the years and always changing them in hope of finding one that's different to the rest and this one fits the bill best one i've ever used fabulous length and doesn't smudge very hard wearing and if i don't take it off at night it's completely in tact in the morning but also comes"	68.3%
lifts well "it makes your lashes look really thick and luscious and lifts well!"	68.2%
decent unfortunately "it's also very clumpy i wouldn't recommend not decent unfortunately"	68.1%
applies well "applies well and looks good"	68.1%
still lifted "i apply at 7 am and come 6 pm my lashes are still lifted"	68.1%
discounted price "one of my favourite mascara's at discounted price"	68.1%
actually liked "possibly the first mascara i've actually liked"	68.0%
quite waterproof "it is quite waterproof but it can smudge slightly when you have excessive watery eyes "	67.6%
eyelash curls "this mascara and some decent eyelash curlers help me achieve the curliest eyelash curls which i thought i'd never achieve!"	67.5%
just the best "i bought this and have moved in to the waterproof version and it’s just the best!"	67.2%
quick delivery "quick delivery"	67.1%
favourite mascara's "one of my favourite mascara's at discounted price"	67.0%
looks nice "easy to remove when taking make up off and it looks nice when applied"	66.9%
nice volume "this separates elongates the lashes and give some nice volume after 2 coats it’s not transferring doesn’t get clumpy and lasts all day"	66.9%
hard to remove "this came unsealed and is really hard to remove"	66.8%
curved brush "like the curved brush it makes it easy to apply"	66.6%
lashes great "fantastic love this product it is lush and not cloggy does nor give you these horrible cloggy spider lashes great buy!"	66.6%
...

Pros [222] of Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid E..	Strength
absolutely brilliant in both products "absolutely brilliant!"	100.0%
excellent product in both products "excellent product"	100.0%
very pleased in both products "very pleased and would recommend"	100.0%
highly recommend in both products "would highly recommend"	99.6%
really good in both products "a really good product "	99.3%
best results in both products "the tip is really fine so gives you the best results"	99.3%
genuine item in both products "genuine item my favourite liner!"	75.0%
works well in both products "i've always used coconut or argan oil to gently remove eye make up i also use waterproof mascara and that works well to remove this"	75.0%
great price in both products "great eyeliner at a great price!"	75.0%
looks great in both products "i ordered the aloy colour as i felt black would look to harsh and the colour looks great quite subtle"	74.8%
waterproof mascara in both products "i've always used coconut or argan oil to gently remove eye make up i also use waterproof mascara and that works well to remove this"	74.8%
very quickly in both products "delivered very quickly"	74.8%
good value in both products "this is also good value for money and will last several months"	74.3%
does n't smudge in both products "this is an excellent eyeliner in terms of easiness to apply make a thin line or thicker depending on how you like it stays and doesn’t smudge and is easy to remove with cleansing wipes"	74.2%
really nice in both products "but it's really nice as a less intense look and also stays on all day"	74.2%
perfect product in both products "perfect product"	74.1%
very happy in both products "very happy with this easy to apply and worth the price i think"	74.0%
lasting and good in both products "overall good formula long lasting and good packaging"	73.8%
staying power in both products "very precise with excellent staying power"	73.4%
nice product in both products "it doesn't 'stay all day' but it is a nice product"	73.4%
great reviews in both products "i read great reviews and this is a fantastic product"	73.2%
highly recommended in both products "highly recommended"	72.6%
would recommend in both products "very pleased and would recommend"	72.4%
much better in both products "but was totally worth it it is so much better than a black classic pencil"	71.9%
buying again in both products "i have recommended this to everyone and i will be buying again!"	71.2%
worth the money in both products "glad it was worth the money"	68.4%
good review in both products "it's had such a good review from her that i'm going to order one myself"	60.1%
brilliant eyeliner "this is a brilliant eyeliner!"	100.0%
excellent eyeliner "this is an excellent eyeliner in terms of easiness to apply make a thin line or thicker depending on how you like it stays and doesn’t smudge and is easy to remove with cleansing wipes"	100.0%
excellent thank "excellent thank you"	99.9%
superb reputation "stila has a superb reputation in the beauty business and the peoplexwhomuse these products also feel as strongly about them"	99.9%
favourite eyeliners "this is one of my favourite eyeliners"	99.3%
favourite eyeliner "my favourite eyeliner"	99.3%
favourite liners "got to be one of my favourite liners i've tried :d"	99.3%
recommended highly "this eyeliner was recommended highly on glamour"	99.1%
nice flick "you can make the line as thick or fine as you like create a nice flick and it is waterproof too"	97.2%
lovely thanks "lovely just what i wanted lovely thanks"	96.8%
super pigmented "super pigmented"	95.6%
eyeliner is amazing "this eyeliner is amazing!"	92.1%
best one out there "used for tighlining as well as a cat eye on a daily basis and this is the best one out there"	91.8%
highly pigmented "highly pigmented goes on smoothly and lasts for ages"	91.6%
really love "really love it"	90.1%
and great colour "fabulous eye liner stays put all day and great colour"	90.0%
lovely eyeliner "lovely eyeliner doesn’t quite stay all day i’d say 5 6 hours more like"	88.9%
good pigment "good pigment"	88.8%
best ever eyeliner "best ever eyeliner!"	88.2%
great pigment "stila create a lovely formula with great pigment and longevity"	88.0%
great eyeliner "great eyeliner at a great price!"	88.0%
looks beautiful "so easy to apply does not budge or fade all day long super black and pigmented it looks beautiful"	75.0%
stayed immaculate "i had it on then ended up in hospital was worried i'd look like a panda but it stayed immaculate the whole time "	75.0%
nice change "the brown is a nice change that gives definition that is much more subtle at least for my skin tone med beige "	75.0%
perfect size "great eyeliner and the applicator is the perfect size"	74.9%
perfect lines "i usually struggle to get perfect lines but this was quick and easy"	74.7%
with confidence "it's a waterproof eyeliner and you can easily wear it a full day with confidence"	74.7%
ultra black "this black is ultra black which i love and doesn't crack so worth it!"	74.7%
waterproof eyeliner "best waterproof eyeliner on the market"	74.7%
ultra thin "stays as long as a needy ex girlfriends bitterness and is ultra thin and easy to apply"	74.6%
wears well "it is long lasting and wears well"	74.6%
lovely formula "stila create a lovely formula with great pigment and longevity"	74.6%
would reccomend "long story short i was in bits all night and this eyeliner stayed with me the entire time supporting me like an emotional crutch & the wings looked just as good as they did when i put them on 10 10 would reccomend"	74.6%
splash proof "definitely splash proof"	74.5%
just perfect "the brush stilos is just perfect"	74.5%
precise application "a lovely strong colour with very easy precise application that lasts all day"	74.5%
aloy colour "i ordered the aloy colour as i felt black would look to harsh and the colour looks great quite subtle"	74.4%
pretty quickly "runs out pretty quickly"	74.4%
pretty good "the brush is pretty good easy to use"	74.4%
very convenient "it is quite easy to apply and very convenient without the need for brushes"	74.4%
nice smooth line "draws a nice smooth line easy to use but i was disappointed with this eyeliner as it smudges quite badly on me"	74.4%
overall good "overall good formula long lasting and good packaging"	74.3%
more lasting "more lasting than the nyx and bourjois versions"	74.3%
super easy "the liquid applies super easy and it is on the watery side unlike other eyeliners of the same category which are much harder to dispense product "	74.3%
great definition "it's easy to apply and has great definition don't waste your time with other eyeliners"	74.2%
more waterproof "definitely the best liner i ever used once you draw your line it's on no smudges no running it's more waterproof than any other big name brands i've tried before"	74.2%
awsome looks "awsome looks great easy to apply"	74.2%
quick and easy "i usually struggle to get perfect lines but this was quick and easy"	74.0%
very pretty "it's actually very pretty but you can't really wear it with eyeshadow as you can't see it"	74.0%
good shake "i love this product just needs a good shake and your away jet black fine lines that look good even in the most novice hands"	73.9%
amazing item "amazing item have used it for years and will continue to use it"	73.7%
going strong "i bought this in november and still going strong after daily use till now february whereas others dried up in a month!"	73.6%
beautiful and easy "beautiful and easy application eyeliner"	73.5%
very precise "it has a very well graduated tip that starts from super fine allowing for very precise application"	73.5%
fantastic product "fantastic product"	73.4%
best waterproof "best waterproof eyeliner ever!"	73.3%
tried loads "trust me i've tried loads"	73.3%
easy and precise "easy and precise application that lasts"	73.0%
eyeliner pens "one of the best eyeliner pens out there"	72.9%
long super "so easy to apply does not budge or fade all day long super black and pigmented it looks beautiful"	72.4%
surprisingly well "the brush is nice and it stays surprisingly well"	71.8%
eyeliner easy "overall a fantastic eyeliner easy to apply great colour and last"	71.8%
precise line "and on first application it was the nib giving a neat precise line and perfect feline flicks"	71.6%
strong black colour "this is the best for having a strong black colour and it will last all day no problem"	71.6%
going price "i regularly buy this eyeliner from amazon and other outlets depending on the going price"	71.4%
really well "stays really well and is very pigmented!"	71.4%
less harsh "i’m dark in complexion but getting on so i get the brown because it’s less harsh"	71.1%
very pigmented "the colour is very pigmented and it stayed all day until i removed it"	70.9%
good liner "good liner"	70.6%
perfect line "delivers a perfect line around the eye"	70.3%
better choice "expensive but is a better choice for oilier eyelids"	70.0%
actually waterproof "only waterproof liquid eyeliner i've found which is actually waterproof!"	69.8%
style applicator "the pen style applicator makes it easy to apply"	69.8%
brand eyeliners "i wore this for only a few hours and it started wearing off just like one of the cheaper brand eyeliners i own"	69.5%
liked this product "i really liked this product which is easy to use"	69.1%
sensitive watery eyes "perfect for those with sensitive watery eyes stays put but comes off with a makeup wipe"	69.1%
recommended this "i have recommended this to everyone and i will be buying again!"	68.6%
favourite liner "genuine item my favourite liner!"	68.6%
looks awesome "easy to remove and looks awesome"	68.6%
quite easily "amazing quality more “splash” proof than water proof but if it doesn’t get wet it would quite easily stay on for days!"	68.5%
love eyeliner "this is an absolute must if you love eyeliner!"	68.1%
steady and holding "i find the thickness of the pen really helps with keeping steady and holding"	67.9%
summer vacations "it has survived many a night out sweaty summer vacations and cry sessions and still lasts overnight if you pass out in it after"	67.8%
daily user "i am a daily user of liquid eyeliner and spent a long time finding one that didn't irritate my eyes i have dry eyes and blepharitis "	67.6%
higher expectations "given the great reviews online i'd higher expectations"	67.5%
lost count "i have tried so many eyeliners that i have lost count"	67.5%
achieve a fine line "stays in place and easy to achieve a fine line along the lashes"	67.4%
nice to use smooth "so nice to use smooth and stays put all day"	67.2%
good price point "works great good price point"	67.1%
eyeliner continues "the search for the perfect ' stays put all day' eyeliner continues"	66.9%
definitely dark colour "but definitely dark colour for the black"	66.6%
happy with the accuracy "very fine point on the pen and so i'm happy with the accuracy"	66.2%
definitely waterproof "definitely waterproof!"	66.2%
precise flicks "really fine so you can draw precise flicks really black and lasts all day even if you work out or get rained on"	66.1%
lasts for hours "and it lasts for hours"	65.4%
very high quality "it's super easy to use stays on without smudging and the quality of the actual pen mechanism is very high quality"	65.3%
chilling watching "i bought 4 of these stila stay all day and applied one to an eyelid to test out whilst chilling watching tv"	65.3%
best eyeliner "actually really good i had no idea what it was going to be like but heard it was good came in a gold box and the eyeliner itself is very good quality is actually the best eyeliner ive ever used i’ve been using it for 2 years now and can’t fault it!"	65.2%
easy to remove "easy to remove and looks awesome"	64.9%
easy to apply "stays as long as a needy ex girlfriends bitterness and is ultra thin and easy to apply"	64.8%
long lasting "it is long lasting and wears well"	64.7%
really smoothly "glides really smoothly and doesn't clump and become patchy if you line over it again and again and doesn't dry down too fast either"	64.7%
hearing the product "the good: easy to remove and correct mistakes something i thought would be hard due to hearing the product lasts 24 hrs "	64.5%
faster to work with "i've been using kat von d and will return to her eyeliner since it's way easier and faster to work with"	64.4%
loved this product "i loved this product"	64.3%
sensitive eyes "i have watery sensitive eyes and every other 'smudgeproof' liner has run or vanished altogether after 10 15 mins"	64.2%
great colours "they dont dry out the nibs dont get ruined before theyve dried out they stay on and they have great colours"	64.0%
happy with this "happy with this as it does not come off during the day"	63.9%
very fine point "very fine point on the pen and so i'm happy with the accuracy"	63.8%
does not stay "however it does not stay put"	63.7%
pencil is fine "the pencil is fine"	63.6%
really easy to "really easy to use and very little smudge"	63.6%
no issues here "i have quite wrinkly lids so struggle to get that smooth line but no issues here"	63.6%
very easy to "very good eyeliner stays put and doesn't smudge and very easy to use"	63.4%
easy to use so fine "easy to use so fine"	63.4%
easy to use so precise "so easy to use so precise"	63.3%
leap of faith "i was put off a bit by the price but i took a leap of faith and it paid off!"	63.1%
will not be disappointed "you will not be disappointed!"	62.9%
brush is nice "the brush is nice and it stays surprisingly well"	62.8%
happy with "i am happy with it although i find it doesn’t go on quite as easily as liquid liner"	62.8%
very important "lasts all day and easy to remove which is very important for me after a long day at work!"	62.6%
very good product "very good product"	62.6%
it's amazing "purchased for my sister in law who says that it's amazing"	62.5%
described and liked "all as described and liked"	62.4%
intense black "lasts all day long easy to apply and love the intense black of it"	62.4%
after multiple uses "my only quibble is the end of the pen can get a bit straggly after multiple uses and defining the end of my wing can be a fiddle at times"	62.4%
solid deep black "it's a beautiful solid deep black hue and is easy to apply"	62.2%
with a nice thin "it is nice and easy to use with a nice thin tip"	62.2%
bloody brilliant "bloody brilliant!"	62.0%
very simple to "a really strong black and very simple to use"	61.9%
perfect ' stays "the search for the perfect ' stays put all day' eyeliner continues"	61.8%
colour & ease "love the colour & ease of this eyeliner fantastic in cold or wet weather unfortunately in hot weather it tends to sweat off onto the lids"	61.7%
best eye liner "the best eye liner i have ever used"	61.6%
very good eyeliner "very good eyeliner stays put and doesn't smudge and very easy to use"	61.6%
found i love "its the first eyeliner that stays put all day that i've found i love it!"	61.6%
beauty business "stila has a superb reputation in the beauty business and the peoplexwhomuse these products also feel as strongly about them"	61.4%
smooth eyeliner "beautiful smooth eyeliner 👌easy to apply lasts all day i love it ❤️❤️❤️"	61.3%
and very black "easy to use and very black"	61.3%
waterproof liner "bought it because i read it's a decent waterproof liner"	61.0%
applies smoothly "it goes on a really rich black and applies smoothly"	61.0%
which is easy to "i really liked this product which is easy to use"	61.0%
last all day no problem "this is the best for having a strong black colour and it will last all day no problem"	60.6%
really rich "it goes on a really rich black and applies smoothly"	60.3%
best liner "best liner i have used"	60.1%
it's as good "i had the black one and loved it so decided to get the brown one for a more discreet look but i don't actually think it's as good"	59.6%
without smudging "the colour is bold and stays all day without smudging"	59.6%
stays so well "i have greasy eyelids too and it just stays so well!"	59.4%
good while "lasts a good while"	59.4%
it's fantastic "i have used stila black stay eyeliner ordered from boots and it’s fantastic"	59.3%
easy to use precise "it is easy to use precise and doesn't go shaky or uneven"	59.3%
love this product "i love this product just needs a good shake and your away jet black fine lines that look good even in the most novice hands"	59.3%
beautiful wings "i love pen eyeliners because they're so much easier to use and create beautiful wings with than other eyeliners"	58.9%
nice texture & look "it goes on easily & has a nice texture & look"	58.8%
6 hours more like "lovely eyeliner doesn’t quite stay all day i’d say 5 6 hours more like"	58.6%
great service "great service very fast!"	58.3%
wonderful eye liner "this is a wonderful eye liner"	58.2%
that is easy to "i have been looking for an eyeliner that doesn't smudge and that is easy to use"	58.2%
definitely stays on all "definitely stays on all day"	58.2%
need for brushes "it is quite easy to apply and very convenient without the need for brushes"	57.8%
day colour is amazing "lasts all day colour is amazing"	57.7%
perfect eyeliner "this is better in my opinion than kat von d but i am still looking for the perfect eyeliner"	57.6%
hope this helps "hope this helps!"	57.5%
easy to hold "love this stuff stays on doesn't seem to smudge at all and it's so easy to hold and put on"	57.3%
fine flicks and lines "i have found the last one i bought particularly "wet" so harder to get precision but usually the tip is very easy to create fine flicks and lines"	57.1%
good i just "so good i just keep buying it"	57.0%
stays on my top lids "all i wanted was an eyeliner that stays on my top lids all day long and this eyeliner certainly does the job"	56.8%
just as good "long story short i was in bits all night and this eyeliner stayed with me the entire time supporting me like an emotional crutch & the wings looked just as good as they did when i put them on 10 10 would reccomend"	56.8%
much easier "now it's much easier :"	56.7%
really strong "a really strong black and very simple to use"	56.6%
more stronger "can be more stronger though in staying power"	56.6%
with no problem "very easy to use glided on in place with no problem"	56.5%
easy application "easy application with precised linings"	56.4%
worth every penny "worth every penny"	56.1%
love this eye liner "love this eye liner!"	55.8%
very good quality "actually really good i had no idea what it was going to be like but heard it was good came in a gold box and the eyeliner itself is very good quality is actually the best eyeliner ive ever used i’ve been using it for 2 years now and can’t fault it!"	55.8%
beautiful eyeliner "such a beautiful eyeliner this will be my third one and it's so worth the money"	55.7%
best eyeliners "stays most of the day but comes of by evening still one of the best eyeliners for a day wear though!"	55.6%
really impressed "i'm really impressed and will definitely buy again!"	55.5%
love my money "used a couple of times and the colour went would love my money back!"	55.4%
best eyeliner i "best eyeliner i’ve used"	55.4%
never fails "i've been using stila eyeliner for years and it never fails"	55.4%
strong colour "a lovely strong colour with very easy precise application that lasts all day"	55.3%
still an improvement "but still an improvement"	55.2%
great product "as described great product and doesn’t rub off on upper bit of my eyelids all throughout the day"	55.0%
easy to apply and long "easy to apply and long lasting"	55.0%
great goes on nicely "found this great goes on nicely"	54.8%
goes on smoothly "it goes on smoothly"	54.6%
like a panda "i had it on then ended up in hospital was worried i'd look like a panda but it stayed immaculate the whole time "	54.4%
i was using previously "i love the brush felt pen nib and this is definitely better than the ud one i was using previously"	54.3%
better than most "its durability is still better than most but the"wings" you draw disappears quite quickly"	54.3%
glides on like a liquid "it glides on like a liquid but has the accuracy of a fine pen"	54.2%
favourite liquid liner "my favourite liquid liner"	54.2%
love a great "wow wow this liner stays on all day and it’s truly black which i love a great buy"	54.2%
good luck girls "good luck girls!"	54.1%
will definitely buy again "i'm really impressed and will definitely buy again!"	53.9%
...